The Moderate Voice - Latest Comments in On the IAF Gaza School Strike

Re: On the IAF Gaza School Strike

EEllis — Fri, 09 Jan 2009 01:49:05 -0000

"The fact that historically Israelis have killed something like 10 Palestinians for every 1 Israeli that&#39s been killed has to enter into the equation somewhere.

Self defense just can&#39t explain away 60 years of occupation, theft and murder. "

You&#39re just dishonest. "Occupation"? Palestine has never been a country and there has never been anything to to "Occupy". Gaza was taken from Egypt after Egypt attacked Israel. I don&#39t think Egypt is the Palestinian homeland. Theft, well as we just learned you must have something before it can be stolen from you, but that&#39s just more pesky facts. And here&#39s a shock killing someone who is trying to kill you or others has never been murder anywhere but in some fantasy world were you must live.

"That&#39s why it&#39s stupid to blame Hamas for the current hostilities anymore than you blame Israel."

Then the opposite would be true but statements have already called that a lie. At least you could be a consistent idiot. Well I guess you are consistently illogical.

Re: On the IAF Gaza School Strike

EEllis — Thu, 08 Jan 2009 20:49:05 -0000

"The fact that historically Israelis have killed something like 10 Palestinians for every 1 Israeli that's been killed has to enter into the equation somewhere.

Self defense just can't explain away 60 years of occupation, theft and murder. "

You're just dishonest. "Occupation"? Palestine has never been a country and there has never been anything to to "Occupy". Gaza was taken from Egypt after Egypt attacked Israel. I don't think Egypt is the Palestinian homeland. Theft, well as we just learned you must have something before it can be stolen from you, but that's just more pesky facts. And here's a shock killing someone who is trying to kill you or others has never been murder anywhere but in some fantasy world were you must live.

"That's why it's stupid to blame Hamas for the current hostilities anymore than you blame Israel."

Then the opposite would be true but statements have already called that a lie. At least you could be a consistent idiot. Well I guess you are consistently illogical.

Re: On the IAF Gaza School Strike

ChrisWWW — Thu, 08 Jan 2009 17:40:52 -0000

Well according to you it&#39s all about the body count. The fact that Israel kills more that Hamas means they get more blame right?

The fact that historically Israelis have killed something like 10 Palestinians for every 1 Israeli that&#39s been killed has to enter into the equation somewhere.

Self defense just can&#39t explain away 60 years of occupation, theft and murder.

At some point the Israelis have to break the cycle of violence. They&#39re the ones in control.

It&#39s counterproductive to talk about Hamas refusing any peace that has Israel in it anywhere

It&#39s pointless, because this isn&#39t really about Hamas. Palestinians have sought peace through the PLO and Fatah. But both organizations were considered too radical in their times and Israel refused to deal with them. That&#39s why more hardline groups have taken their place. Now Israel has to deal with the monster they&#39ve created.

That is just about the single stupidest thing I have ever seen you write, and while we disagree on a lot, you normally aren&#39t stupid. How about Hamas firing NO rockets during a cease fire?

Who&#39s going to blink first? It&#39s a circular argument, but it shows how both sides are more similar than they are different. That&#39s why it&#39s stupid to blame Hamas for the current hostilities anymore than you blame Israel.

Re: On the IAF Gaza School Strike

ChrisWWW — Thu, 08 Jan 2009 12:40:52 -0000

Well according to you it's all about the body count. The fact that Israel kills more that Hamas means they get more blame right?

The fact that historically Israelis have killed something like 10 Palestinians for every 1 Israeli that's been killed has to enter into the equation somewhere.

Self defense just can't explain away 60 years of occupation, theft and murder.

At some point the Israelis have to break the cycle of violence. They're the ones in control.

It's counterproductive to talk about Hamas refusing any peace that has Israel in it anywhere

It's pointless, because this isn't really about Hamas. Palestinians have sought peace through the PLO and Fatah. But both organizations were considered too radical in their times and Israel refused to deal with them. That's why more hardline groups have taken their place. Now Israel has to deal with the monster they've created.

That is just about the single stupidest thing I have ever seen you write, and while we disagree on a lot, you normally aren't stupid. How about Hamas firing NO rockets during a cease fire?

Who's going to blink first? It's a circular argument, but it shows how both sides are more similar than they are different. That's why it's stupid to blame Hamas for the current hostilities anymore than you blame Israel.

Re: On the IAF Gaza School Strike

AustinRoth — Thu, 08 Jan 2009 02:28:39 -0000

"When the cease fire of 6 months ago was instituted why didn&#39t Israel lift the blockade after Hamas sharply cut back the rocket attacks?"

That is just about the single stupidest thing I have ever seen you write, and while we disagree on a lot, you normally aren&#39t stupid. How about Hamas firing NO rockets during a cease fire?

Your point seems to be that Hamas has some amount of rocket fire that they should be able to launch without any fear of reprisal, and that Israel should use the techniques of bad parenting, &#39Well, little Johnny isn&#39t stealing or lying as often lately, so let&#39s give him a reward for such good behavior!"

Re: On the IAF Gaza School Strike

EEllis — Thu, 08 Jan 2009 01:26:05 -0000

"Being good or bad at prosecuting an immoral and counterproductive war isn&#39t the issue"

Well according to you it&#39s all about the body count. The fact that Israel kills more that Hamas means they get more blame right?

"Did it ever occur to you that Israel is the recipient of the preponderance of criticism because they are the perpetrators of the greatest preponderance of death?"

Now you want to change your argument again..........

It&#39s counterproductive to talk about Hamas refusing any peace that has Israel in it anywhere, but ignore that because you don&#39t want to talk about it so it doesn&#39t matter. Changing arguments in mid stride, ignoring facts, you are really invested in Israel being the one and only Bad Guy. Nothing that will challenge it will be tolerated right?

Re: On the IAF Gaza School Strike

EEllis — Thu, 08 Jan 2009 01:16:30 -0000

I could buy it if it was the first time someone had used a school for a base. Funny thing. there is a YouTube video from 2007 showing mortars firing in that same school.And no offence they print Palestinian reports as headlines without being able to validate.

Re: On the IAF Gaza School Strike

ChrisWWW — Wed, 07 Jan 2009 22:21:43 -0000

How about when they pulled out of Gaza? Come on your ignoring reality! Sure there is a strong settler lobby who would move in and bulldoze what you would call "Palestine" pushing everyone out. However it is in the minority. Most Israelis would quickly go for giving territory to a "Palestine" state if it meant peace.

First off, when they pulled out of Gaza, they still maintained effective military control of the area. It was like a prison where the guards and the warden controlled it from the outside rather than in. Second, when they pulled out of Gaza, they took even more land from the West Bank, so it was a net loss of land for the Palestinians.

Third, I think you&#39re right that "most" Israelis would favor giving up land for peace. But the people in charge are doing and have done the exact opposite for 60 years. As a result the Palestinian population is more radicalized and more ready to jump into the arms of groups like Hamas (which saw its popularity waning until the recent attack on Gaza).

So if they were bad at it then they would be the good guys?

Being good or bad at prosecuting an immoral and counterproductive war isn&#39t the issue.

Re: On the IAF Gaza School Strike

AustinRoth — Wed, 07 Jan 2009 21:28:39 -0000

Chris -

"When the cease fire of 6 months ago was instituted why didn't Israel lift the blockade after Hamas sharply cut back the rocket attacks?"

That is just about the single stupidest thing I have ever seen you write, and while we disagree on a lot, you normally aren't stupid. How about Hamas firing NO rockets during a cease fire?

Your point seems to be that Hamas has some amount of rocket fire that they should be able to launch without any fear of reprisal, and that Israel should use the techniques of bad parenting, 'Well, little Johnny isn't stealing or lying as often lately, so let's give him a reward for such good behavior!"

Re: On the IAF Gaza School Strike

Rudi — Wed, 07 Jan 2009 21:20:49 -0000

jawa report
dhimmi watch

http://jonswift.blogspot.com/2008/11/president-...

http://online.wsj.com/article/SB122991429181825...

http://cunningrealist.blogspot.com/2008/12/i-ne...

http://cunningrealist.blogspot.com/2008/12/simp...

http://cunningrealist.blogspot.com/2008/09/risk...

http://www.nytimes.com/2008/12/14/business/14sc...

http://www.newsmeat.com/fec/bystate_detail.php?...

Perp walk for the crooks on Wall Street.
http://www.reuters.com/article/InvestmentOutloo...

E Trade mortgage meltdown
http://www.reuters.com/article/newsOne/idUSTRE4...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5gydQNZVmWU&eurl...

Article from JP and another from AP say that the mortor fite was from a “street close to the school”.

JP:

Two residents of the area near UN school that was shelled by the IDF on Tuesday said that they had seen a small group of terrorists firing mortar rounds from a street close to the school. The two spoke with The Associated Press by telephone on condition of anonymity for fear of reprisal.

AP:

Israel’s military said its shelling — the deadliest single episode since Israeli ground forces invaded Gaza Saturday — was a response to mortar fire from within the school and said Hamas militants were using civilians as cover.
Two residents of the area who spoke by telephone said they saw a small group of militants firing mortar rounds from a street near the school, where 350 people had gathered to get away from the shelling. They spoke on condition of anonymity for fear of reprisal.

Mortars are not stationary artillery, a PU dropping off the mortARS doesn’t make the school a base.

I could buy into this if the school was an isolated incident. But this from UKTimesOnline:

Israeli mortar rounds blasted a United Nations-run school that had been converted into a refugee shelter for hundreds of Palestinians displaced by the ten-day war in Gaza, killing more than 40 people.
It was one of three UN schools hit by Israeli ordnance yesterday. The strike against the Fakhora school in the northern town of Jabaliya was the deadliest single attack of an already blood-soaked offensive.

Re: On the IAF Gaza School Strike

EEllis — Wed, 07 Jan 2009 21:17:21 -0000

"That argument is a distraction and ultimately self defeating. In any case, the flip side is more important: When has Israel ever said that it would coexist with a Palestinian State? When the cease fire of 6 months ago was instituted why didn&#39t Israel lift the blockade after Hamas sharply cut back the rocket attacks?"

How about when they pulled out of Gaza? Come on your ignoring reality! Sure there is a strong settler lobby who would move in and bulldoze what you would call "Palestine" pushing everyone out. However it is in the minority. Most Israelis would quickly go for giving territory to a "Palestine" state if it meant peace. Israel has started down that path several times and always palestinian organizations have attacked it. So Hamas slowed down the rocket attacks, not quit by your assertion just cut back, maybe Israel should of done just half a blockade? Why would they (Israel) not try and stop Hamas from bringing in rockets to shoot? Come on!! Weapons are the reason for the tunnels, that&#39s why the ships smuggle stuff in, don&#39t parrot propaganda that a 5 yo should see thru.

"Did it ever occur to you that Israel is the recipient of the preponderance of criticism because they are the perpetrators of the greatest preponderance of death?"

So if they were bad at it then they would be the good guys? That&#39s stupid and illogical. Besides since Hamas seems to make a goal of getting civilians dead I think they more than shoulder their share of the burden.

Re: On the IAF Gaza School Strike

EEllis — Wed, 07 Jan 2009 20:26:05 -0000

"Being good or bad at prosecuting an immoral and counterproductive war isn't the issue"

Well according to you it's all about the body count. The fact that Israel kills more that Hamas means they get more blame right?

"Did it ever occur to you that Israel is the recipient of the preponderance of criticism because they are the perpetrators of the greatest preponderance of death?"

Now you want to change your argument again..........

It's counterproductive to talk about Hamas refusing any peace that has Israel in it anywhere, but ignore that because you don't want to talk about it so it doesn't matter. Changing arguments in mid stride, ignoring facts, you are really invested in Israel being the one and only Bad Guy. Nothing that will challenge it will be tolerated right?

Re: On the IAF Gaza School Strike

EEllis — Wed, 07 Jan 2009 20:16:30 -0000

Re: On the IAF Gaza School Strike

ChrisWWW — Wed, 07 Jan 2009 17:21:43 -0000

How about when they pulled out of Gaza? Come on your ignoring reality! Sure there is a strong settler lobby who would move in and bulldoze what you would call "Palestine" pushing everyone out. However it is in the minority. Most Israelis would quickly go for giving territory to a "Palestine" state if it meant peace.

Third, I think you're right that "most" Israelis would favor giving up land for peace. But the people in charge are doing and have done the exact opposite for 60 years. As a result the Palestinian population is more radicalized and more ready to jump into the arms of groups like Hamas (which saw its popularity waning until the recent attack on Gaza).

So if they were bad at it then they would be the good guys?

Being good or bad at prosecuting an immoral and counterproductive war isn't the issue.

Re: On the IAF Gaza School Strike

ChrisWWW — Wed, 07 Jan 2009 17:20:38 -0000

What we&#39ve been hearing is greatly preponderent, inappropriate criticism of Israel.

Did it ever occur to you that Israel is the recipient of the preponderance of criticism because they are the perpetrators of the greatest preponderance of death?

Re: On the IAF Gaza School Strike

ChrisWWW — Wed, 07 Jan 2009 17:18:52 -0000

Oops, those damn facts getting in the way again. What the hell you&#39ll just ignore them.

I&#39m willing to believe the UN reports which put the number of civilian dead at over 125. If that number is true, I&#39m wrong and I&#39m sorry. But that number is not insignificant, nor is it insignificant that Gazans have been suffering under an occupation and siege for 60 years after having been expelled from their homes.

Tell me this though, when has Hamas ever said that it would coexist with Israel? That improving conditions would make any difference to them?

That argument is a distraction and ultimately self defeating. In any case, the flip side is more important: When has Israel ever said that it would coexist with a Palestinian State? When the cease fire of 6 months ago was instituted why didn&#39t Israel lift the blockade after Hamas sharply cut back the rocket attacks?

Re: On the IAF Gaza School Strike

rudi — Wed, 07 Jan 2009 16:20:49 -0000

Articles from JP and another from AP say that the mortar fire was from a “street close to the school”.

JP:

Two residents of the area near UN school that was shelled by the IDF on Tuesday said that they had seen a small group of terrorists firing mortar rounds from a street close to the school. The two spoke with The Associated Press by telephone on condition of anonymity for fear of reprisal.

AP:

Israel’s military said its shelling — the deadliest single episode since Israeli ground forces invaded Gaza Saturday — was a response to mortar fire from within the school and said Hamas militants were using civilians as cover.
Two residents of the area who spoke by telephone said they saw a small group of militants firing mortar rounds from a street near the school, where 350 people had gathered to get away from the shelling. They spoke on condition of anonymity for fear of reprisal.

Mortars are not stationary artillery, a PU dropping off the mortARS doesn’t make the school a base.

I could buy into this if the school was an isolated incident. But this from UKTimesOnline:

Israeli mortar rounds blasted a United Nations-run school that had been converted into a refugee shelter for hundreds of Palestinians displaced by the ten-day war in Gaza, killing more than 40 people.
It was one of three UN schools hit by Israeli ordnance yesterday. The strike against the Fakhora school in the northern town of Jabaliya was the deadliest single attack of an already blood-soaked offensive.

Re: On the IAF Gaza School Strike

DLS — Wed, 07 Jan 2009 16:18:30 -0000

Chris WWW, sorry for the delay, but time constraints here and slow response limit my current use of this site.

What we&#39ve been hearing is greatly preponderent, inappropriate criticism of Israel. First, all the howling has been about Israel, is it being terrible, is it violating international law, it "must" refrain from this, that, and anything else that might give it an advantage over its enemy, and of course the joke of a UN is nearly all one-sided against Israel. Now the critics are forced to admit the rocket attacks are wrong, but they still want Israel to stop (to stop succeeding or winning against the terrorist, we must ask, if honest) and they howl about how Israel is equally at fault here (a lie) or that its response is disproportionate (a lie). Currently we&#39re seeing howling for a truce as soon as possible, lasting as long as possible. Too many people are obscessed with getting a truce (and ending Israel&#39s successes against the terrorists) rather than with seeing a long-term solution and a proper resolution of this (including cessation of the rocket attacks, which require nothing from Israel in exchange).

"As far as much of the Arab world is concerned we are as complicit as Israel in those civilian deaths, and that is precisely why so many Americans have a problem with it. People like DLS would like to trivialize this rather than see it in it&#39s entirety"

Why would you make up a blatantly false statement like this with absolutely no basis in fact or history to support it? STOP THE FICTION.

Re: On the IAF Gaza School Strike

EEllis — Wed, 07 Jan 2009 16:17:21 -0000

How about when they pulled out of Gaza? Come on your ignoring reality! Sure there is a strong settler lobby who would move in and bulldoze what you would call "Palestine" pushing everyone out. However it is in the minority. Most Israelis would quickly go for giving territory to a "Palestine" state if it meant peace. Israel has started down that path several times and always palestinian organizations have attacked it. So Hamas slowed down the rocket attacks, not quit by your assertion just cut back, maybe Israel should of done just half a blockade? Why would they (Israel) not try and stop Hamas from bringing in rockets to shoot? Come on!! Weapons are the reason for the tunnels, that's why the ships smuggle stuff in, don't parrot propaganda that a 5 yo should see thru.

"Did it ever occur to you that Israel is the recipient of the preponderance of criticism because they are the perpetrators of the greatest preponderance of death?"

So if they were bad at it then they would be the good guys? That's stupid and illogical. Besides since Hamas seems to make a goal of getting civilians dead I think they more than shoulder their share of the burden.

Re: On the IAF Gaza School Strike

ChrisWWW — Wed, 07 Jan 2009 12:20:38 -0000

What we've been hearing is greatly preponderent, inappropriate criticism of Israel.

Did it ever occur to you that Israel is the recipient of the preponderance of criticism because they are the perpetrators of the greatest preponderance of death?

Re: On the IAF Gaza School Strike

ChrisWWW — Wed, 07 Jan 2009 12:18:52 -0000

Oops, those damn facts getting in the way again. What the hell you'll just ignore them.

I'm willing to believe the UN reports which put the number of civilian dead at over 125. If that number is true, I'm wrong and I'm sorry. But that number is not insignificant, nor is it insignificant that Gazans have been suffering under an occupation and siege for 60 years after having been expelled from their homes.

Tell me this though, when has Hamas ever said that it would coexist with Israel? That improving conditions would make any difference to them?

That argument is a distraction and ultimately self defeating. In any case, the flip side is more important: When has Israel ever said that it would coexist with a Palestinian State? When the cease fire of 6 months ago was instituted why didn't Israel lift the blockade after Hamas sharply cut back the rocket attacks?

Re: On the IAF Gaza School Strike

DLS — Wed, 07 Jan 2009 11:18:30 -0000

Chris WWW, sorry for the delay, but time constraints here and slow response limit my current use of this site.

What we've been hearing is greatly preponderent, inappropriate criticism of Israel. First, all the howling has been about Israel, is it being terrible, is it violating international law, it "must" refrain from this, that, and anything else that might give it an advantage over its enemy, and of course the joke of a UN is nearly all one-sided against Israel. Now the critics are forced to admit the rocket attacks are wrong, but they still want Israel to stop (to stop succeeding or winning against the terrorist, we must ask, if honest) and they howl about how Israel is equally at fault here (a lie) or that its response is disproportionate (a lie). Currently we're seeing howling for a truce as soon as possible, lasting as long as possible. Too many people are obscessed with getting a truce (and ending Israel's successes against the terrorists) rather than with seeing a long-term solution and a proper resolution of this (including cessation of the rocket attacks, which require nothing from Israel in exchange).

"As far as much of the Arab world is concerned we are as complicit as Israel in those civilian deaths, and that is precisely why so many Americans have a problem with it. People like DLS would like to trivialize this rather than see it in it's entirety"

Why would you make up a blatantly false statement like this with absolutely no basis in fact or history to support it? STOP THE FICTION.

Re: On the IAF Gaza School Strike

EEllis — Wed, 07 Jan 2009 02:54:22 -0000

"And I&#39d be surprised if half of the people Israel has killed in Gaza over the last few days are actually part of Hamas. The average age in Gaza is something ridiculously low like 17. The area is the most densely populated on earth. Those facts just don&#39t work in the favor of surgical strikes"

Oops, those damn facts getting in the way again. What the hell you&#39ll just ignore them.

Listen it&#39s not about right and wrong. You&#39ve picked your side and it&#39s obvious that you&#39ll ignore anything you don&#39t like Chris. Tell me this though, when has Hamas ever said that it would coexist with Israel? That improving conditions would make any difference to them? Your attitude is more than a little condescending towards Hamas. They say they want Israel gone. That they will accept nothing else. So you think they are lying? That they are ignorant or simple? That they are something besides sincere in their beliefs? Hamas did everything they could to get Israel to attack and to try and maximize the number of palestinian casualties, but Israel&#39s the bad guy here?

Re: On the IAF Gaza School Strike

JSpencer — Wed, 07 Jan 2009 00:48:54 -0000

I don&#39t think anyone really knows how many civilians have been killed in GAZA so far. How could they? Yes, Hamas is all about using death of civilians for propaganda purposes, if they had any respect for the lives of their civilian population they would never have spent to much time and effort provoking Israel. That said, Israel&#39s response is done with our blessing in terms of weapons and resources. As far as much of the Arab world is concerned we are as complicit as Israel in those civilian deaths, and that is precisely why so many Americans have a problem with it. People like DLS would like to trivialize this rather than see it in it&#39s entirety, but looking at only fragments of the picture and pretending to understand doesn&#39t cut it. This problem was referred to recently as the Forever War, and I&#39ve yet to see any "solutions" that are going to keep if from being just that.

Re: On the IAF Gaza School Strike

ChrisWWW — Wed, 07 Jan 2009 00:14:53 -0000

Out of 500 reported dead only 100 are reported civilian......seems they are doing a pretty good job.

Q: What do you call 100 unnecessarily killed civilians?

A: Dead.